I live in Barnsley, South Yorkshire. I’m from Wakefield, but we moved to Barnsley for cheaper house prices in 2004 and we’ve made a home here; Himself works in the town centre and we both like our semi-rural locality. I work in Leeds so sometimes shop there, but I do most of my shopping online. Until recently, there was an Evans in Barnsley, so I would always go in when I was in town.
In February, while there with a friend, I realised that the Evans is now a Costa Coffee. The Dorothy Perkins and the Burton’s Menswear, which are also part of the Arcadia group, are still next door, but Evans is no more. This left me with precisely ONE shop where I could find something to fit - in the tiny Inspire section of the smallish New Look.
Sometimes, Evans does incredibly well. The top I’m wearing in my last post came from there, and I do like it for unusual tops for dressyish occasions. But I don’t buy my basics there, partly because it’s expensive and partly because the quality can be rubbish. I don’t mind having clothes that I know will only last a year or so, but I don’t want to spend ~£30-£40 on them, you know? I’ll buy my one-season-wears from Yours Clothing for £15 instead.
If Evans has lost its business in Barnsley, it needs to look at WHY. At a time when it feels like fatshion bloggers are still spending their money, and when Simply Be are OPENING shops, and when Yours Clothing and Marisota and Simply Be and others are doing a roaring trade online and on eBay, Evans needs to look at why it has lost so many of its core customers. This is something I’ve seen in the community for years, but it hasn’t happened yet.
(I would wager though that it’s partly due to cost - Evans is expensive, and Barnsley is demographically very poor.)
But it isn’t all doom and gloom for Barnsley town centre. I went there on Friday with my mum (who, at a size 18/20, has a fair amount of thin privilege that means she buys most of her clothes at M&S, BHS, Wallis, even places like River Island sometimes) and was whingeing at the fact that Evans has gone. We had a wander round the market, though, looking for material stalls, which is what Barnsley market used to be known for. We found just two material stalls. But we also found THREE plus-sized clothes stalls.
The first one was located right down the bottom of the outdoor market, and the stallholder told us he is only there Tuesdays and Fridays. His stock was all ex-Evans, ex-Ann Harvey, ex-Tesco, and so on, and for prices starting from just £5. I got two tops - one Ann Harvey (which surely would have cost at least £40 in store) and one Evans. My mum got a blue denim skirt which she’s been after for ages. All for the princely sum of £17.
The second and third stalls I didn’t look at much, but one was inside and one was out, nearest the town centre. From what I saw, they were selling some of the brands that I’ve seen on the Yours website, for slightly lower prices. There was a great stripy skater dress for £9.99, but I couldn’t justify it.
If you do go into Barnsley and fancy a shopping friend, let me know and I will definitely come along :)